Public housing advocates marched on the offices of Related Companies at Hudson Yards last year to protest plans to demolish and privatize the Fulton and Elliot-Chelsea houses. A resolution introduced last weekend at the DSA’s New York City convention urging members to stand with FEC tenants in their fight failed to pass. Photo/Joe Maniscalco
By Joe Maniscalco
Last week in a story called ‘Will the Blue Wave End Up Swamping the DSA, too?’, Work-Bites asked if the Democratic Party’s corporate-controlled leadership, after winning both the House and Senate, will now succeed in shutting out and/or coopting the Democratic Socialists of America and its populist agenda.
That may still be an open question—but in New York City at least, the DSA is doing a fine job of turning itself inside out all on its own.
The New York City Chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America [NYC-DSA] considered nine resolution during its biennial convention held in Midtown Manhattan on Nov. 14. All of them, including one to launch a new membership drive to attract more Black and Latinx members into the organization passed.
There was one outstanding exception.
The only resolution that a majority of NYC-DSA delegates voted down at last weekend’s biennial convention was one from a group of predominantly Black and Latinx NYC-DSA members calling on their socialist comrades to stand with tenants at the Fulton and Elliot-Chelsea public houses [FEC] and oppose the Mamdani administration’s ongoing campaign to privatize and demolish their communities.
“It’s so hypocritical that somebody put up a resolution before ours saying they need more Latinos and Blacks to join DSA,” FEC tenant Jackie Lara told Work-Bites this week. “Yeah, you wanna get more Blacks and Latinos [to join the DSA]—but we were the first ones you let down on the day of the voting.”
“It’s so hypocritical that somebody put up a resolution before ours saying they need more Latinos and Blacks to join DSA. Yeah, you wanna get more Blacks and Latinos [to join the DSA]—but we were the first ones you let down on the day of the voting.”
Before New York City voters made him a one-and-done mayor last year, Eric Adams had relentlessly pushed a so-called “public-private partnership” scheme to level the FEC public houses and replace them with a series of towering new high-rises consisting of mostly luxury housing built between 9th and 10th avenues on Manhattan’s west side.
Related Companies and Essence Development—the same private developers behind the glitzy Hudson Yards development located nearby—would hold a 99-year lease and control the whole thing.
The new apartments promised to existing FEC public housing residents—including those elderly residents living at the Chelsea Addition on West 27th Drive—would only come after years of massive disruption and dislocation, and require tenants to surrender their Section 9 housing protections and accept the lesser safeguards offered under project-based Section 8 rules.
Community Board 4 officially rejected the demolition scheme last year after considering months of pushback from FEC tenants and their allies determinedly opposed to the plan.
Repairing and maintaining the existing FEC houses, they argued, would be far cheaper than demolishing the tree-lined neighborhood communities and replacing them with a towering mix of mostly market-rate apartments appealing to the wealthy well-to-do.
The New York City Housing Authority [NYCHA], they further argued, was really just trying to profit off of Chelsea real estate—one of the most valuable pieces of land in town.
“NYCHA planned all along to take their revenue out of Chelsea—and they had Related Companies as a willing partner because they’re going to make a killing,” architect and Community Board 4 Land Use Committee member David Holowka told Work-Bites at time.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s DSA-endorsed administration, including Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants head Cea Weaver, however, have wasted no time since then in picking up right where Adams left off—pushing the demolition and privatization of the FEC public houses just as hard and ruthlessly as the previous administration had.
And while Mayor Mamdani has held face-to-face meetings with private developers and some FEC tenants supportive of demolition and privatization—he has consistently ignored similar meeting requests from FEC tenants opposed to the plan.
“How is it that we’ve been so vocal and active in this fight against demolition, yet we do not get the opportunity to speak with the mayor?” Elliot-Chelsea Tenants Association VP Celines Miranda told Work-Bites this week. “This includes the current Elliott-Chelsea Tenant Association Board. We are the resident leaders, and both the FEC Tenants Against Demolition tenant organizers and the anti-demolition Tenant Association Board are being dismissed.”
Work-Bites reached out to the Mayor’s Office for comment on this story—but those requests, too, have been ignored.
“We want to believe that the mayor isn’t choosing to align himself with billionaire developers,” Miranda continued. “There is no logic behind this type of partnership when Zohran Mamdani believes that billionaires should be non-existent.”
The ongoing plan to demolish and “rebuild” the FEC houses, according to Miranda, will only make the pockets of Related executives and their Essence Development partners a whole lot deeper than they already are.
“If the Mayor is consciously choosing to side with Related Companies, then he’s choosing profit over people—and it’s hypocrisy at its finest,” she said.
Lara, meanwhile, makes no bones about who she believes is actually responsible for the FEC resolution failing to pass during last weekend’s NYC-DSA convention.
“I just think that Cea Weaver is behind it, telling them don’t vote for the resolution, because she's a big DSA member,” Lara told Work-Bites. “It’s so weird because out of nine resolutions ours was the only one that didn’t pass.”
One of the resolutions that easily passed during last weekend’s convention included one urging Congress Member Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to run for president in 2028.
“It’s been very eye-opening for us to see that there's definitely a power base connected with the elected [officials],” longtime Chelsea resident and Chelsea Public Housing Coalition member Caitlin Cahill told Work-Bites this week. “There are people now in the DSA who were not there when I joined five years ago. It does seem like the DSA is very divided, and that there is this push towards a [public] housing model that embraces the financialization of housing.”
Wherever they go, FEC tenants continuing to fight back against demolition and privatization say they see a well-coordinate and concerted effort by pro-development forces—including groups like Open New York—eagerly pressing their own agenda.
“It feels as if all the YIMBYs are infiltrating the scene, a scene in which they have no real interest in protecting [public housing],” Miranda said. “You see them all over: at the community boards, public housing committees, NYCHA—and even DSA.”
“It feels as if all the YIMBYs are infiltrating the scene, a scene in which they have no real interest in protecting [public housing]. You see them all over: at the community boards, public housing committees, NYCHA—and even DSA.”
Efforts to reach the DSA for comment on this story were also unsuccessful.
The final vote that sent the FEC resolution down to defeat during last weekend’s biennial convention was 179 in favor—230 against.
Still, FEC tenants continuing to fight the demolition and privatization of their communities report receiving lots of love and support, too, from DSA members on Nov. 14.
DSA members will have an opportunity to further express that love and support for FEC tenants fighting demolition and privatization when the coalition rallies outside Gracie Mansion, East 88th Street and East End Avenue, on Saturday, Dec. 5, starting at 3:30 p.m.
This, of course, is not the only issue putting the DSA’s socialist bona fides to the test.
Many young socialists agitating for a real break from establishment New York City politics and a status quo that puts profits over peopole also object to Mayor Mamdani’s ongoing failure to support New York City home care workers fighting hard to pass the “No More 24” bill and an end to the 24-hour work day.
New York City’s socialist mayor also continues to ignore requests to meet with the New York City Organization of Public Service Retirees [NYCOPSR] to discuss Intro. 1008—long-suffering legislation that if enacted would prevent any further attempts to strip New York City municipal retirees of their traditional Medicare benefits and push them into a profit-driven Medicare Advantage plan.
Mayor Mamdani—perhaps surpassing AOC herself as the DSA’s biggest star in the country right now—has argued that the retiree bill is not needed.